Skip to content
Head-to-head comparison

Black Dog Plumbing vs North Alabama Plumbing Company: Water Heater Specialists Compared

Compare 2 verified plumbers in Alabama by Google rating, reviews and services. Data verified November 18, 2026.

November 2, 2026 4 min read Data verified November 18, 2026

Black Dog Plumbing and North Alabama Plumbing Company are two plumbing businesses in Alabama with published Google ratings and review histories. This guide compares their ratings, services, locations and the themes in verified customer reviews so you can decide which one to call.

Both businesses publish their rating, review count, phone number, address and services on Google. This comparison uses those records as they appeared on November 18, 2026. We do not rank one as objectively “better”; instead we show where each listing is strongest so you can match it to your job.

Quick side-by-side comparison

Aspect Black Dog Plumbing North Alabama Plumbing Company
Google rating 5 / 5 5 / 5
Review count 477 422
City Chelsea, AL Huntsville, AL
Service focus Water heater repair and replacement Water heater repair and replacement
Services listed Faucet & Fixtures, Water Heater Repair, Leak Detection, Pipe Repair & Repiping Leak Detection, Faucet & Fixtures, Toilet Repair, Water Heater Repair
Phone +1 659-305-1411 +1 256-690-4886
Emergency language Indicated in listing/reviews Indicated in listing/reviews

Black Dog Plumbing at a glance

Black Dog Plumbing is a water heater repair and replacement business listed in Chelsea, AL. It holds a 5/5 rating from 477 Google reviews.

  • Address: 10468 Chelsea Rd, Chelsea, AL 35043
  • Services: Faucet & Fixtures, Water Heater Repair, Leak Detection, Pipe Repair & Repiping
  • Website: blackdog-plumbing.com

“Tommy went above & beyond in getting this job completed. We needed him back quickly & was ready to do whatever it takes to help me. Then we had another worker for Sheetrock not show up many of times &…”

— Linda Frederick, Edited 1 week ago

North Alabama Plumbing Company at a glance

North Alabama Plumbing Company is a water heater repair and replacement business listed in Huntsville, AL. It holds a 5/5 rating from 422 Google reviews.

“The city was doing some testing on a fire hydrant in my yard and per the city coincidentally the water line in water box sprung a leak that same day. Of course the waterline that was damaged was on my…”

— Brad Stephens, 1 month ago

Ratings and review volume compared

Black Dog Plumbing has 477 reviews at 5/5, while North Alabama Plumbing Company has 422 reviews at 5/5. The higher headline rating belongs to Black Dog Plumbing; the larger review base belongs to Black Dog Plumbing. A larger base can be useful context, but read the recent reviews rather than relying on the average alone.

Services and specialities

Black Dog Plumbing lists Faucet & Fixtures, Water Heater Repair, Leak Detection, Pipe Repair & Repiping. North Alabama Plumbing Company lists Leak Detection, Faucet & Fixtures, Toilet Repair, Water Heater Repair. Choose the business whose listed services match the job you need; call to confirm the exact scope before booking.

Price levels and call-out costs

Neither Google listing is a substitute for a written quote. Price levels are often omitted; where present they describe a relative range rather than a fixed fee. Ask both businesses for the diagnostic fee, hourly or flat-rate pricing, parts markup and after-hours charges.

Location and service area

Black Dog Plumbing is listed at 10468 Chelsea Rd, Chelsea, AL 35043; North Alabama Plumbing Company is listed at 2918 Meridian St N B, Huntsville, AL 35811. Confirm that your address falls inside their service area before booking a visit.

Verdict: which plumber should you choose?

Data-led verdict

  • Choose Black Dog Plumbing if you need water heater repair and replacement in Chelsea, AL and its review profile fits your job.
  • Choose North Alabama Plumbing Company if you need water heater repair and replacement in Huntsville, AL or prefer the larger review base.
  • Before you book either: confirm the Alabama licence, insurance certificate, written quote and availability.

Read the Black Dog Plumbing profile · Read the North Alabama Plumbing Company profile

FAQ

Which plumber has the higher rating?

Black Dog Plumbing has 5/5 versus 5/5. Ratings can change as new reviews arrive.

Which plumber has more reviews?

Black Dog Plumbing has 477 reviews, compared with 422.

Do both handle emergency calls?

At least one listing uses emergency or same-day language. Confirm the after-hours fee and response window directly with each business.

How was this comparison researched?

We used the public Google Business Profile fields collected on November 18, 2026, plus published review text. No business paid for inclusion and no prices were invented.

Compare both profiles

See the full EEAT profile for each business, including verified review quotes and contact details.

Black Dog Plumbing · North Alabama Plumbing Company

Map of these plumbers

Peta Lokasi Interaktif (2 Titik)

How this page was researched

Experience, expertise, authoritativeness and trust — documented.

Written by
FindPlumber Editorial The FindPlumber editorial team writes practical, plain-English guides about plumbing costs, repairs and hiring licensed professionals in the United States.
Data verified
November 18, 2026
Method
Head-to-head comparison using only verified Google Business Profile fields and published reviews from the Alabama dataset. No prices, services or review text were invented, and no business paid for inclusion.

Always confirm licence, insurance and the final quote directly with the business. FindPlumber is an independent directory and does not perform plumbing work.